Restrictive covenants (non-competition and non-solicitation)

A restrictive covenant is a contract term that limits a person's ability to compete with a business, or to solicit its customers or employees, after the relationship ends. In British Columbia, courts rarely enforce employee non-competes and will not rewrite overbroad clauses, but they routinely enforce reasonable non-competes given by sellers on the sale of a business.

How BC law treats it

Restrictive covenants are restraints of trade and are presumptively unenforceable unless shown to be reasonable. In employment, the Supreme Court of Canada requires that the covenant be clear and unambiguous, protect a legitimate proprietary interest, and be no wider than reasonably necessary in time, territory and the activity restrained (Shafron v KRG Insurance Brokers (Western) Inc, 2009 SCC 6; Elsley v J.G. Collins Insurance Agencies Ltd, [1978] 2 SCR 916). Courts will not rewrite or 'read down' an overbroad covenant; it falls entirely. A non-solicitation clause will usually protect the employer adequately, so a non-compete is hard to justify. A covenant given by a vendor on the sale of a business is assessed more leniently, because the buyer paid for goodwill and the parties bargained on equal footing (Payette v Guay inc, 2013 SCC 45). Reasonable limits on time, territory and activity tied to the business sold are commonly enforced. Covenants in shareholders agreements fall between the two, and courts look at whether the person was really selling goodwill or was essentially an employee. A restrictive covenant added after employment starts should be supported by fresh consideration, such as a signing payment or raise. In BC, Rosas v Toca, 2018 BCCA 191 means a variation without new consideration is not automatically void, but relying on that is risky. BC, unlike Ontario, has no general statutory ban on employee non-competes as of October 2026; enforceability is decided under the common law.

What it means for your business

For buyers of a business, a properly drafted vendor non-compete protects the goodwill they paid for and is often a closing condition. For employers, an overreaching non-compete gives a false sense of security: if challenged, it will likely be struck, leaving no protection at all. Narrow non-solicitation and confidentiality clauses tailored to real client relationships are far more reliable. Sellers and departing employees should know which covenants a court is likely to enforce before deciding their next move. Example: When a Richmond accounting practice is sold, the vendor agrees not to offer bookkeeping services within 50 kilometres of the practice's Richmond office for three years, which a court is likely to uphold. The practice's junior employees instead sign 12 month non-solicitation clauses limited to clients they served.

Risks and common mistakes

Using a broad employee non-compete with no geographic limit, or a vague term like 'Greater Vancouver', which courts treat as ambiguous. Assuming a court will cut an overbroad covenant down to something reasonable instead of striking it entirely. Adding a non-compete to an existing employee's contract without fresh consideration. Applying the strict employment test to a vendor covenant in a sale, or the lenient sale test to an employee. Relying on a non-compete when a narrow non-solicitation and confidentiality clause would protect the business better.

Key authorities

  • Shafron v KRG Insurance Brokers (Western) Inc, 2009 SCC 6
  • Payette v Guay inc, 2013 SCC 45
  • Elsley v J.G. Collins Insurance Agencies Ltd, [1978] 2 SCR 916
  • Rosas v Toca, 2018 BCCA 191

Frequently asked questions

Are non-compete agreements enforceable in BC?

Employee non-competes are presumed unenforceable and are rarely upheld, especially if broad or vague. Non-competes given by a seller when selling a business are judged more leniently and are often enforced if reasonable in time, territory and activity.

Will a BC court shorten an unreasonable non-compete?

No. Under Shafron v KRG Insurance Brokers, courts will not rewrite an overbroad restrictive covenant to make it reasonable. If the clause is too wide or ambiguous, it is struck entirely and the employer is left with no restriction.

What is the difference between a non-compete and a non-solicit?

A non-compete stops a person from working in a competing business at all. A non-solicit only stops them from approaching the business's customers or employees. Because a non-solicit is less restrictive, BC courts are much more willing to enforce it.

Related terms

Non-competition agreement | Non-solicitation agreement | Employment contract | Goodwill | Confidentiality agreement

Drafting or challenging a non-compete or non-solicitation clause? Talk to a Fulcrum business lawyer.

General information about British Columbia and Canadian law, current to October 2026. It is not legal advice; get advice on your own situation.