Wilful misconduct

Wilful misconduct is deliberate wrongdoing, or reckless disregard of a known risk, by someone who knows the act is wrong or harmful. In British Columbia commercial contracts it most often appears as an exception to limitation of liability, exclusion and indemnity clauses, so a party cannot rely on those protections for its own intentional misconduct.

How BC law treats it

Wilful misconduct is not a separate cause of action. Most claims, such as negligence or breach of contract, do not require it. The term matters mainly because contracts use it to define what a party's liability protections do not cover. A typical clause caps liability at the fees paid, or excludes indirect losses, except for losses caused by a party's gross negligence, wilful misconduct or fraud. Courts interpret these terms according to the contract as a whole. Wilful misconduct generally means intentionally doing something wrongful, or acting with reckless indifference to whether it is wrongful, knowing harm is likely. It is more serious than gross negligence, which is a marked departure from the standard of care. Contracts often define the terms to avoid argument. Even without a carve-out, a court may decline to enforce an exclusion clause. Under Tercon Contractors Ltd v British Columbia (Transportation and Highways), 2010 SCC 4, the court asks whether the clause covers the conduct, whether it was unconscionable when made, and whether an overriding public policy, such as deliberate fraud or conduct that is clearly abusive, justifies refusing enforcement. Statutes and insurance policies also use the phrase. Many liability policies exclude losses caused intentionally by the insured, and some statutes protect officials except for wilful misconduct or bad faith.

What it means for your business

The wilful misconduct carve-out decides whether a liability cap actually holds. A supplier that deliberately stops performing to pressure a customer for a price increase may lose its cap, exposing it to unlimited damages. A customer negotiating a technology or services contract should make sure the carve-out covers deliberate breach and data misuse. Defining the term clearly avoids an expensive dispute over what it means after the fact. Example: A Vancouver software vendor's contract caps liability at 12 months of fees except for wilful misconduct. When the vendor deliberately shuts off the customer's access during a billing dispute, the customer argues the cap does not apply.

Risks and common mistakes

Believing a plaintiff must prove wilful misconduct to recover in ordinary negligence or contract claims. Leaving wilful misconduct undefined in a liability cap carve-out. Treating wilful misconduct and gross negligence as the same standard. Assuming a liability cap protects a party who deliberately breaches the contract. Overlooking intentional act exclusions in the party's own insurance policy.

Key authorities

  • Tercon Contractors Ltd v British Columbia (Transportation and Highways), 2010 SCC 4

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between gross negligence and wilful misconduct?

Gross negligence is a marked and serious departure from the standard of care. Wilful misconduct goes further: the person acts deliberately, or with reckless indifference, knowing the conduct is wrong or likely to cause harm. Contracts often carve out both from liability caps.

Does a limitation of liability clause cover deliberate breach?

Often not. Many contracts expressly exclude wilful misconduct and fraud from the cap. Even without that wording, a BC court applying Tercon may refuse to enforce an exclusion clause where public policy outweighs freedom of contract.

Related terms

Gross negligence | Exclusion clauses | Indemnification | Breach of contract | Technology contracts | Damages

Negotiating a liability cap or indemnity? Talk to a Fulcrum contracts lawyer.

General information about British Columbia and Canadian law, current to October 2026. It is not legal advice; get advice on your own situation.