BC applies the common law of offer and acceptance. An offer must be definite enough that acceptance creates a contract. Advertisements, price lists and requests for proposals are usually invitations to treat, not offers. An offer ends if it is rejected, revoked before acceptance, lapses after its stated or a reasonable time, or is met with a counter-offer, which rejects the original and replaces it (Hyde v Wrench (1840), 49 ER 132). A promise to keep an offer open is binding only if the offeree gives consideration for it or the promise is under seal, which creates an option. A letter of intent or term sheet may look like an offer but is often expressly non-binding apart from clauses such as confidentiality and exclusivity. Whether it binds depends on the wording and on whether all essential terms are agreed. In BC real estate, a buyer usually signs a contract of purchase and sale as an offer, and the seller accepts, counters or rejects it. Subject clauses (financing, inspection) create a binding contract with conditions, and the buyer must make honest, reasonable efforts to satisfy them (Wiebe v Bobsien, a BC case). In construction and public procurement, submitting a compliant bid can form a preliminary contract ("Contract A") that limits how the owner may evaluate bids (R v Ron Engineering & Construction (Eastern) Ltd, [1981] 1 SCR 111; MJB Enterprises Ltd v Defence Construction (1951) Ltd, [1999] 1 SCR 619). Offers and acceptances can be made by email, online click or electronic signature under the Electronic Transactions Act, SBC 2001, c 10, unless a statute requires another form.
Business owners create contracts more easily than they expect: an email that says "agreed" to a definite proposal may be binding. Equally, a reply that changes a single term is a counter-offer that kills the original deal. Knowing when your quote, proposal or bid becomes binding, and when you can still withdraw, helps you negotiate without being locked in early and protects you when the other side tries to walk away. Example: A Victoria contractor emails a fixed price quote, and the customer replies accepting it but adding a new completion date. That reply is a counter-offer, so there is no contract until the contractor agrees to the new date.
Treating a reply that changes terms as an acceptance rather than a counter-offer. Promising to hold an offer open without receiving anything for it or signing under seal, then assuming the promise binds. Signing a letter of intent without stating clearly which parts are binding. Assuming an email exchange cannot form a binding contract. Accepting a bid that does not comply with the tender terms, exposing the owner to claims from other bidders.
Can I withdraw an offer before it is accepted in BC?
Generally yes. An offer can be revoked any time before acceptance, as long as the revocation reaches the other party. The exception is an option, where the offeree has paid or given something to keep the offer open, or the promise to keep it open is under seal.
Is a counter-offer a rejection?
Yes. A counter-offer rejects the original offer and replaces it with a new one. The original offer cannot later be accepted unless the person who made it renews it.
Can an email create a binding contract in BC?
Yes. Under the Electronic Transactions Act, an offer and acceptance can be made by email or other electronic means. If the essential terms are agreed and the parties intended to be bound, an email exchange can form a contract.
Contract | Option agreement | Electronic contracts | Unilateral contracts | Procurement
Negotiating a deal and unsure what you have agreed to? Talk to a Fulcrum business contracts lawyer.
General information about British Columbia and Canadian law, current to October 2026. It is not legal advice; get advice on your own situation.