Not every breach allows termination. At common law, the innocent party may terminate only for a breach that goes to the root of the contract, often described as depriving it of substantially the whole benefit it bargained for, or for a repudiation, where the other party shows it will not perform. For lesser breaches, the remedy is damages and the contract continues. A material breach or repudiation does not end the contract automatically. The innocent party must elect either to accept the repudiation and treat the contract as terminated, or to affirm it and insist on performance (Guarantee Co of North America v Gordon Capital Corp, [1999] 3 SCR 423). The election should be communicated clearly. A party that terminates for a breach that turns out not to be serious enough has itself repudiated the contract and may be liable in damages. Commercial contracts often define material breach, list events of default and require written notice and a cure period before termination. Courts generally enforce those terms as written, and failing to follow the notice process can invalidate a termination. The old doctrine of fundamental breach, once used to avoid exclusion clauses, was retired in Tercon Contractors Ltd v British Columbia (Transportation and Highways), 2010 SCC 4, which replaced it with a test of interpretation, unconscionability and overriding public policy. Damage claims for breach are subject to the Limitation Act, SBC 2012, c 13.
Deciding whether a breach is material is one of the highest risk calls in a commercial relationship. Terminate too quickly and your business becomes the party in breach. Wait too long or keep accepting performance and you may be taken to have affirmed the contract. Clear definitions, notice and cure periods and termination rights in supplier, distribution, licensing and service agreements make that call more predictable. Example: A Kamloops distributor's supplier stops delivering product for three months and tells the distributor it is selling direct. The distributor gives written notice that it accepts the repudiation, terminates the agreement and sues for lost profits.
Terminating for a minor breach, which can turn the terminating party into the party in breach. Ignoring the contract's notice and cure provisions before terminating. Continuing to accept performance for months after a serious breach, which may be treated as affirming the contract. Failing to communicate a clear election to terminate or affirm. Relying on the old fundamental breach doctrine to escape an exclusion clause after Tercon.
Can I cancel a contract if the other side breaches it?
Only if the breach is serious enough to go to the root of the contract, amounts to a repudiation, or the contract gives you a termination right. For lesser breaches, you can claim damages but must keep performing. Wrongful termination can make you liable.
What is the difference between material breach and fundamental breach?
Both describe a serious breach going to the root of the contract. Fundamental breach was also a doctrine used to set aside exclusion clauses, but the Supreme Court of Canada retired that use in Tercon in 2010.
Does a material breach end the contract automatically?
No. The innocent party must choose whether to accept the breach and terminate, or affirm the contract and continue. That choice should be communicated clearly and promptly, usually in writing.
Breach of contract | Termination clauses | Waiver | Damages | Exclusion clauses | Default
General information about British Columbia and Canadian law, current to October 2026. It is not legal advice; get advice on your own situation.