Dispute resolution

Dispute resolution is the set of methods used to settle legal disagreements, from negotiation and mediation to arbitration and court litigation. In British Columbia, domestic commercial arbitration is governed by the Arbitration Act, small claims go to the Civil Resolution Tribunal or Small Claims Court, and larger disputes proceed in the BC Supreme Court.

How BC law treats it

Most business disputes are resolved by negotiation, often after a demand letter. Mediation is a confidential, non-binding process with a neutral mediator. In BC Supreme Court actions, a party can compel the others to attend mediation by delivering a Notice to Mediate under the Notice to Mediate (General) Regulation, within the time limits that regulation sets. Arbitration is a private, binding process. Domestic arbitrations are governed by the Arbitration Act, SBC 2020, c 2, and international commercial arbitrations by the International Commercial Arbitration Act. If a contract contains an arbitration clause and one party sues in court, the other can generally have the court action stayed. A domestic award can be appealed to the Court of Appeal for British Columbia only on a question of law, with leave of a justice of that court or the consent of all parties, and the arbitration agreement can exclude appeals altogether (s. 59). Court litigation depends on the amount. The Civil Resolution Tribunal decides small claims up to $5,000 online, Small Claims Court in the Provincial Court hears claims up to $35,000, and the BC Supreme Court hears larger claims and claims for injunctions and other equitable remedies. A dispute resolution clause in a contract can set an escalation path (executive negotiation, then mediation, then arbitration or court), choose the governing law and forum, the seat and rules of any arbitration, and confidentiality. Clear drafting avoids a costly preliminary fight about where the dispute will be heard.

What it means for your business

The dispute resolution clause decides how fast, how private and how expensive a future dispute will be. Arbitration offers privacy, a chosen decision maker and limited appeals, but it can cost more than court for small claims. Mediation resolves many disputes early. Choosing the right method in the contract, and the right forum when a dispute arises, saves time and money. Example: A Vancouver software vendor's licence agreement requires 30 days of executive negotiation, then mediation, then arbitration seated in Vancouver. When a customer disputes fees, the parties settle at mediation within two months.

Risks and common mistakes

Using a vague clause that does not say whether arbitration is mandatory or optional. Failing to name the seat, rules and number of arbitrators. Choosing arbitration for low value disputes where small claims court would be cheaper. Starting a court action despite a binding arbitration clause and facing a stay application. Treating mediation as a formality and attending without authority to settle.

Key authorities

Frequently asked questions

Is arbitration better than going to court in BC?

It depends. Arbitration is private, lets parties choose the decision maker and limits appeals, but the parties pay the arbitrator. Court is public and slower but can be cheaper for smaller or simpler disputes.

Can I force the other side to mediate in BC?

In a BC Supreme Court action, a party can deliver a Notice to Mediate under the Notice to Mediate (General) Regulation, which requires the other parties to attend a mediation, subject to the timing rules in that regulation.

Can an arbitration award be appealed in BC?

Under the Arbitration Act, a domestic award can be appealed to the Court of Appeal for British Columbia only on a question of law, with leave of a justice of that court or the consent of all parties. The parties can exclude appeals in their arbitration agreement.

Related terms

Arbitration | Mediation | Alternative dispute resolution | Commercial dispute | Civil litigation | Venue

Drafting a dispute resolution clause or facing a dispute? Talk to a Fulcrum litigation lawyer.

General information about British Columbia and Canadian law, current to October 2026. It is not legal advice; get advice on your own situation.