
A buyer and a seller can agree on a price in an afternoon. Agreeing on what is actually being sold usually takes far longer, and it often moves more money than the last round of price negotiation.
That question, share purchase vs asset purchase in BC, decides who carries the company's history, how much tax each side pays, whether employees and leases come across automatically, and which consents are needed before closing.
Sellers usually want to sell shares. Buyers usually want to buy assets. Neither preference is wrong, but each carries legal consequences under British Columbia law that should be understood before a letter of intent is signed.
This guide explains how each structure works under the Business Corporations Act (BC), where BC rules and federal rules diverge, how liabilities, taxes, employees and contracts are treated, and how to decide which structure suits your deal.
In a share purchase, the buyer acquires the shares of the company from its shareholders. The company itself stays the same legal person, with the same assets, contracts, employees, permits, tax history and liabilities. Only its owners change.
In an asset purchase, the buyer acquires selected assets from the company: equipment, inventory, intellectual property, goodwill, customer contracts and sometimes real estate. The selling company stays with its shareholders, keeps whatever was excluded, and keeps its liabilities unless the buyer expressly assumes them.
The seller is a different person in each case. In a share deal, the shareholders sell and receive the price. In an asset deal, the company sells, and the proceeds land inside the company rather than with its owners. Most of the tax and liability differences below follow from that one point.
The preferences are predictable because the economics are predictable.
What a buyer gains in an asset purchase:
What a seller gains in a share sale:
Whichever structure is chosen, the price should reflect who bears which risk. A buyer that accepts a share purchase usually asks for stronger indemnities, a holdback or a lower price. A seller that agrees to an asset sale often asks for a higher price to offset the additional tax.
The articles of most private BC companies restrict share transfers, typically by requiring the directors' consent. That consent has to be obtained and documented before the transfer is registered.
A shareholders agreement may add rights of first refusal, tag-along rights, approval requirements or a drag-along right that allows a majority to deliver 100 percent of the shares to an arm's-length buyer. Check these before negotiating with a buyer, not after.
If a buyer wants all the shares but a minority holder will not sell, section 300 of the Business Corporations Act (BC) allows a compulsory acquisition only after an offer is accepted by holders of at least nine-tenths of the shares involved, excluding shares the acquirer already holds. In most private deals, that threshold makes it a poor substitute for a drag-along clause.
The directors approve an asset sale in the ordinary course of managing the business. If the company is selling all or substantially all of its undertaking outside the ordinary course of business, section 301 of the Business Corporations Act (BC) also requires a special resolution of shareholders.
The default special majority is two-thirds of the votes cast, and the articles may set it as high as three-quarters. Shareholders are entitled to dissent and be paid fair value for their shares, so a buyer should confirm that the approval and dissent process has been followed before closing.
An asset purchase is really a series of transfers, each with its own legal requirements:
British Columbia repealed its bulk sales legislation in 2004. There is no general statutory procedure for notifying the seller's creditors, so the buyer's protection comes from searches, statutory clearances and the purchase agreement.
Because the company does not change, every liability stays with it, whether or not anyone knows about it at closing. That includes tax reassessments, lawsuits, product and warranty claims, unpaid wages and vacation pay, regulatory breaches and environmental contamination on its land.
The buyer manages that exposure through due diligence, representations and warranties, specific indemnities for identified risks, a holdback or escrow of part of the price, and sometimes representation and warranty insurance.
The buyer generally takes only the liabilities it agrees to assume. But several BC statutes attach obligations to the business or the asset, not to the contract:
Tax is where federal and provincial rules meet. Income tax and GST are federal, under the Income Tax Act (Canada) and the Excise Tax Act (Canada). Provincial sales tax and property transfer tax are BC taxes with their own rules. Each should be modelled separately for both sides.
A sale of shares is an exempt financial service and does not attract GST. An asset sale generally does, unless the parties can make the section 167 election under the Excise Tax Act, which is available where the buyer acquires all or substantially all of the property reasonably necessary to carry on the business. Real property raises separate GST rules and should be reviewed on its own.
PST does not apply to a transfer of shares. In an asset purchase, the buyer generally pays PST on taxable tangible personal property such as equipment and furniture, at the general rate of 7 percent, subject to exemptions such as inventory acquired for resale. Vehicles and certain other assets have their own rules. Because PST is provincial, the GST election does not remove it.
If an asset purchase includes BC land, the Property Transfer Tax Act (BC) imposes tax when the transfer is registered, calculated on fair market value. The general rates are 1 percent on the first $200,000, 2 percent to $2 million and 3 percent above that, with a higher rate on the residential portion of value above $3 million and additional tax for foreign entities on residential property where it applies.
A purchase of the shares of a company that owns land does not involve a registered transfer, so it does not currently attract property transfer tax under the Act. That can be a significant saving on a real estate-heavy business. It also means the buyer inherits the company's historical tax cost in the land and any liabilities attached to it, and the law should be checked as at the date of the transaction rather than assumed.
In a share purchase, nothing changes for employees. The employer is the same company, employment continues, and accrued obligations such as vacation pay and length of service carry on unaffected.
In an asset purchase, the selling company remains the employer until the buyer offers employment and the employee accepts. Employees the buyer hires keep their length of service for the purposes of the Employment Standards Act (BC) under section 97. Courts have also frequently recognized prior service in assessing common law reasonable notice for employees who continue with the buyer.
Employees the buyer does not hire remain the seller's responsibility. The seller may owe compensation for length of service under the Act and reasonable notice at common law. The purchase agreement should state clearly who bears those costs, because the answer affects the true price.
In a unionized business, successorship under the Labour Relations Code (BC) is determined by the Labour Relations Board, not by the parties' agreement.
In an asset purchase, every contract the buyer wants must be assigned, and many require consent. A landlord, supplier or key customer asked to consent may refuse or use the request to renegotiate terms.
A share purchase avoids formal assignment because the contracting party does not change. But many contracts contain change-of-control clauses that treat a sale of shares as an assignment or give the other party a right to terminate. Commercial leases, loan agreements, franchise agreements, distribution agreements and software licences are common examples.
Either way, identify the material contracts early, read the assignment and change-of-control terms, and make the key consents conditions of closing.
Share purchase due diligence looks at the whole company, because the buyer inherits all of it:
Asset purchase due diligence focuses on title to the assets being bought and the ability to transfer them:
Gaps in corporate records discovered in a share deal can often be repaired before closing, sometimes with a court application under sections 229 and 230 of the Business Corporations Act (BC). Repairs take time, so they are best identified early.
A share purchase agreement BC buyers sign usually contains broader representations and warranties than an asset purchase agreement, because the buyer is taking the whole company. Both should address:
Non-competition clauses given by a seller are assessed more generously than those in ordinary employment contracts, but they must still be reasonable in duration, territory and scope. In Shafron v. KRG Insurance Brokers (Western) Inc., 2009 SCC 5, a BC case, the Supreme Court of Canada declined to enforce a restrictive covenant whose territory was ambiguous and refused to rewrite it. Precise drafting is what makes these clauses enforceable.
BC courts read purchase agreements as commercial contracts, in light of the circumstances known to both parties when they were made, under Sattva Capital Corp. v. Creston Moly Corp., 2014 SCC 53. The parties also owe each other a duty of honest performance under Bhasin v. Hrynew, 2014 SCC 71.
Two federal statutes can apply regardless of structure. Larger transactions that exceed the thresholds in the Competition Act (Canada) require pre-merger notification and a waiting period before closing. Acquisitions by non-Canadian buyers can require notification or review under the Investment Canada Act, including national security review, which is not tied to deal size.
These are federal processes. Neither involves a BC regulator, and both should be built into the timeline at the letter of intent stage.
Post-closing disputes usually involve claims for breach of a representation or warranty, indemnity claims, purchase price adjustment disagreements or allegations of misrepresentation. Most proceed in the Supreme Court of British Columbia under the Supreme Court Civil Rules, which has jurisdiction over contract claims, injunctions and equitable relief.
Many agreements send disputes to arbitration under the Arbitration Act (BC), or send working capital disputes to an independent accountant. In BC Supreme Court proceedings, a party can generally require mediation under the Notice to Mediate (General) Regulation.
Timing is critical. The Limitation Act (BC) sets a basic two-year limitation period running from discovery, but most purchase agreements also set survival periods and notice requirements. A claim that is not notified within the contractual period can fail before the limitation question is ever reached.
There is no default answer. The right structure depends on the specific business, and the deciding factors are usually these:
Some deals combine the two. A common approach is a pre-closing reorganization in which the wanted business is moved into a new subsidiary, often on a tax-deferred basis under section 85 of the Income Tax Act, and the buyer then purchases the subsidiary's shares. These reorganizations engage anti-avoidance rules and, where land moves into the new company, can trigger property transfer tax. They should be designed with tax advisors well before closing.
An asset purchase usually gives a buyer more control over liabilities and a better tax cost for the assets. A share purchase can still be the better choice where the business depends on contracts, permits or land that are difficult or costly to transfer. The answer turns on the specific business and the price.
Under the current Property Transfer Tax Act (BC), tax is triggered by registering a transfer of land, so buying the shares of a landholding company does not currently attract property transfer tax. The buyer inherits the company's tax cost in the land and its liabilities, and the law should be confirmed at the time of the transaction.
No. The buyer must offer employment and the employee must accept. For employees who do move across, section 97 of the Employment Standards Act (BC) treats their employment as continuous for the purposes of the Act. Employees who are not hired remain the seller's responsibility.
Not directly. The exemption applies to individuals disposing of qualified small business corporation shares, among other qualifying property. When a company sells its assets, the company is the seller and the gain arises inside the company, so the exemption is not available on that sale.
If the company is selling all or substantially all of its undertaking outside the ordinary course of business, section 301 of the Business Corporations Act (BC) requires a special resolution, and shareholders have the right to dissent and be paid fair value. Smaller asset sales are generally a matter for the directors.
In an asset purchase, the lease must be assigned, which almost always requires the landlord's consent. In a share purchase, the tenant does not change, but many commercial leases treat a sale of shares as an assignment. Either way, the lease terms decide whether consent is needed and on what conditions.
The choice between a share purchase and an asset purchase is not a technicality to settle after the price. It decides who carries the company's past, how much of the price survives tax, and which third parties can delay or block closing.
The deals that run smoothly are the ones where both sides understood the structure, and priced it, before the letter of intent was signed. The ones that stall are usually the ones where tax, consents or liabilities were left until due diligence.
If you are buying or selling a business in BC, preparing a company for sale, or negotiating a share purchase agreement or asset purchase agreement, speak with our business law team about the structure that fits your deal before terms are fixed.